Arxo LawExecutable canons

Canons, running

International instruments as executable models. Every answer names the article, the facts, and what stays with the tribunal or the Council.

  • ●Established by the rules
  • ○Not established on these facts
  • ◆Left to the tribunal or the organ, with the question it must decide
Same Facts, Two InstrumentsHardship: a threefold rise in cost

After the contract was concluded, events beyond the seller's control made performance far more onerous. The tribunal has found that the equilibrium of the contract was fundamentally altered and that the events could not reasonably have been taken into account. The seller asked for renegotiation without undue delay.

  1. EstablishedIs there hardship?Principles art. 6.2.2
  2. EstablishedMay the seller request renegotiation?Principles art. 6.2.3(1)
  3. Left to the tribunalIs the seller exempt from damages?CISG art. 79

Is there hardship? sha256:5860eb69…dd2fCheck this answerOpen this case

Same Vote, Two AnswersA procedural vote

Nine members vote in favour of a procedural decision. No permanent member votes against. The letter of article 27(2) does not require the concurring votes of the permanent members.

  1. EstablishedIs the decision adopted?art. 27(2)
  2. Not establishedIs it blocked by a permanent member?art. 27(3)

Is the decision adopted? sha256:fe9c532d…3eb7Check this answerOpen this case

CanonsOne site per canon

  1. UNIDROIT Principles 2016 and CISG 1980

    UNIDROIT, Rome, 2016 · UNCITRAL, Vienna, 1980

    Hardship, limitation, battle of forms, remedies for non-performance, and the Convention's Article 7(2) bridge.

    Left to the tribunal

    picc.law.arxo.io

  2. Charter of the United Nations, 1945

    San Francisco, 26 June 1945

    Worked votes of the Security Council, membership, the army that was never raised, and article 51 where the text is silent.

    Left to the Council

    charter.law.arxo.io